Bay Village Of Sarasota
8400 VAMO ROAD, Sarasota, FL, 34231 · 9419665611
Nursing HomeMedicare CertifiedMedicaid CertifiedUpdated 2026-05-20
3.0
★★★☆☆
Overall Rating
Health Inspection
3.0
Staffing
4.0
Quality Measures
4.0
95
Licensed Beds
4.0
Staffing Rating
Bay Village of Sarasota holds an overall 3-star rating from CMS, which puts it in the average range compared to nursing homes nationwide. That overall score is built from three separate ratings, and it's worth looking at each one individually because they tell different stories. The health inspection rating is also 3 stars, meaning inspectors found a number of citations that land roughly in line with what you'd see at a typical facility - not a red flag, but worth asking the facility directly about what was cited and how they addressed it. The staffing rating is a stronger 4 stars, which is good news for families. It means residents are getting more hands-on nursing time relative to the number of people living there, and in day-to-day life that can translate to quicker responses, more attentive care, and staff who aren't stretched too thin. The quality measures rating also comes in at 4 stars, reflecting above-average outcomes across 15 clinical indicators like how well the facility manages pain, prevents falls, avoids unnecessary hospitalizations, and maintains residents' physical functioning.
The reason the overall rating sits at 3 stars despite two strong sub-scores is that CMS weighs the health inspection rating heavily in the final calculation. So even when staffing and care outcomes are solid, a middling inspection score can pull the composite down. For families, that means Bay Village has real strengths worth recognizing, especially around staffing and resident health outcomes, but it's a good idea to review the inspection history and ask questions before making a final decision.
💼 Navigating costs for a loved one? Speak with an elder law attorney.Find one free →
Questions to ask when visiting
1. How many residents does each certified nursing assistant care for during the day shift, and does that ratio change at night or on weekends?
2. How long have most of your direct care staff been working here, and what is your turnover rate for CNAs and nurses over the past year?
3. If my loved one has a problem or a complaint, who do I contact, and can you walk me through exactly what happens after I report it?
4. How do you handle residents who need help getting to the bathroom quickly, and what steps do you take to prevent falls and pressure sores?
5. What does a typical day look like for a resident who does not have family visiting, from the time they wake up through the evening?
6. Has this facility been cited for any deficiencies in the last two state inspections, and can I see those inspection reports before I make a decision?
"For more guidance on evaluating facilities, see our guide to [questions to ask when choosing a Florida nursing home](/blog/questions-to-ask-before-choosing-a-nursing-home-in-florida)."
About CMS Star Ratings
CMS assigns 1–5 star ratings to Medicare and Medicaid-certified nursing homes based on three domains: health inspections, staffing levels, and quality measures. The overall rating is a weighted composite.
A 5-star overall rating does not guarantee excellence in every domain — inspect each sub-rating independently. Data is updated quarterly.
🚛 Planning a move for a family member? Senior relocation specialists.Get quotes →
Data sourced from CMS Care Compare. Last updated via nightly pipeline.