NEW CARLTON REHAB AND NURSING CENTER, L L C
405 CARLTON AVE, BROOKLYN, NY, 11238 · 7187896262
Nursing HomeMedicare CertifiedMedicaid Certified
4.0
★★★★☆
Overall Rating
Health Inspection
3.0
Staffing
4.0
Quality Measures
5.0
148
Licensed Beds
4.0
Staffing Rating
New Carlton Rehab and Nursing Center holds an overall 4-star rating, which means it performs above average compared to other nursing homes nationwide. That overall score is a composite picture built from three separate ratings, each measuring something different about how the facility operates and cares for its residents.
On health inspections, the facility earned 3 stars, which is average. This reflects the number and seriousness of any citations found during state inspections, so it suggests there are no major red flags, but there is some room for improvement in that area. Staffing comes in at 4 stars, meaning nurses and aides are spending more time with residents than you'd typically see elsewhere - that can translate to more attentive day-to-day care and shorter response times when a resident needs help. The standout score here is Quality Measures, which hits 5 stars. This is the highest possible rating and covers 15 clinical and physical health outcomes for residents, things like how well pain is managed, whether residents are experiencing falls, or how their mobility holds up over time. A 5-star score in this category is a strong sign that residents are genuinely thriving under the care being provided. Taken together, the above-average staffing and excellent health outcomes are doing a lot of the heavy lifting to bring that overall rating to 4 stars, even with the middling inspection score pulling things back slightly.
💼 Navigating costs for a loved one? Speak with an elder law attorney.Find one free →
Questions to ask when visiting
1. How many residents does each certified nursing assistant typically care for during the day shift, and does that number change at night or on weekends?
2. How long have most of your nursing staff been working here, and what do you do when you have an open shift - do you use agency staff or ask your own employees to cover?
3. Can you walk me through exactly what happens when a resident falls or has a medical emergency, from the moment it occurs to when the family is notified?
4. What does a typical Tuesday look like for a resident - what time do they wake up, eat, and what activities are actually available to them that day?
5. What was your most recent state inspection score, and can I see the last inspection report before I leave today?
6. If my loved one has a complaint or feels unsafe, what is the specific process for reporting it, and who outside of this facility can they contact?
For more guidance on evaluating facilities, see our guide to [questions to ask when choosing a Florida nursing home](/blog/questions-to-ask-before-choosing-a-nursing-home-in-florida).
About CMS Star Ratings
CMS assigns 1–5 star ratings to Medicare and Medicaid-certified nursing homes based on three domains: health inspections, staffing levels, and quality measures. The overall rating is a weighted composite.
A 5-star overall rating does not guarantee excellence in every domain — inspect each sub-rating independently. Data is updated quarterly.
🚛 Planning a move for a family member? Senior relocation specialists.Get quotes →
Data sourced from CMS Care Compare. Last updated via nightly pipeline.